A thatched property that was badly damaged by fire almost 3 years ago could be rebuilt with a clay tile roof. It was on the night of 26th September 2021 that Merlins Cottage on Elm Lane, Calbourne was lost to a blaze that ripped through the quaint holiday home. More than 40 firefighters were called in to tackle the fire, with the incident continuing for more than 12 hours. In August 2022, homeowner Mrs Brown sought planning permission from the Isle of Wight Council to reinstate the thatched roof, as well as installing 4 new windows and raising the chimney stacks to comply with regulations. The local authority agreed with the plans and granted permission the following month. Now, 2 years on, a fresh planning application has been submitted seeking to replace the fire-damaged thatched roof with a clay tile roof instead, as well as 4 new first floor windows. If the Council agrees with the new plans, the roof will be constructed using reclaimed red clay peg tiles. Locals have until the end of September to comment on the plans here, with a decision set to be made by the Isle of Wight Council in early October. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sy9xDvIKOUw
FIRE-HIT THATCHED COTTAGE COULD NOW BE REBUILT WITH CLAY ROOF TILES
- Trending
- Comments
- Latest
MAIN ROAD IN YARMOUTH CLOSED AMID EMERGENCY INCIDENT
13th September 2026
MULTIPLE VEHICLE SMASH INVOLVING 2 DOGS BRINGS FAIRLEE ROAD TO A STANDSTILL
14th September 2026
13-YEAR-OLD BOY INJURED AFTER COLLISION WITH CAR IN RYDE
14th September 2026
TRADING STANDARDS SEARCH SHANKLIN VAPE SHOP AFTER TOBACCO CONCERNS RAISED
18th September 2026
STORAGE TANKS AND 20 TANKERS BEING MOBILISED FOR MAJOR APPLEY SEWER REPAIR
18th September 2026
WIN A £35,000 CASH FORTUNE OR BESPOKE VW CAMPER FOR £2 WITH APEX COMPETITION
18th September 2026
FREE SATURDAY PARKING PLAN FOR ISLE OF WIGHT TAKES STEP FORWARD
18th September 2026
ISLE OF WIGHT’S CRAIG BROWN CLAIMS BRONZE ON EUROPEAN RANKING DEBUT
18th September 2026
TOP STORIES THIS WEEK
-
ANGUS, JACK AND JILL LOOKING FOR FOREVER HOMES AFTER BEING TAKEN INTO ISLE OF WIGHT CARE
-
MAIN ROAD IN YARMOUTH CLOSED AMID EMERGENCY INCIDENT
-
MULTIPLE VEHICLE SMASH INVOLVING 2 DOGS BRINGS FAIRLEE ROAD TO A STANDSTILL
-
13-YEAR-OLD BOY INJURED AFTER COLLISION WITH CAR IN RYDE
-
“DOES THE COUNCIL THINK THIS IS FAIR?” READER REVEALS EXPERIENCE OF NEW DIY CHARGES AT THE TIP
.
Sign up to our daily newsletter
Sign up to the daily newsletter and to get our top Isle of Wight news stories sent to you inbox every day.

© 2024 Island Echo Ltd. (10015091) is a company registered in England and Wales. Registered address: Fortis House, Cothey Way, Ryde, Isle of Wight PO33 1QT. VAT: 358464857 (V5)














































































Thing’s like this should be common sense, no place for thatched roofs after been destroyed. Should now meet all current fire regs etc.
Ah, the dreaded word ‘should’. Yeah let’s paint the world magnolia
I’d always assumed that thatched cottages would al be listed buildings but, given that they’re making this application that must not be the case.
It would be a shame to lose one of our few remaining thatched rooves but I imagine finding the expertise to rebuild one of those must be getting harder and harder these days. If done sensitively and with appropriate materials, the tile roof should match the adjacent building once they’re finished.
Plenty of thatches still left….but once ravaged by fire, it makes a lot of sense for owners to be allowed to make a safer home
Thatchers are hard to find, prices & insurance are massive…
There are plenty of valid reasons to get rid of thatch and they easily outweigh aesthetic considerations (if you aren’t rolling in moolah). Thatched roofs can cost £25-30k to replace and have a short life. They are ravaged by crows for nest building materials and need constant upkeep. Insurance costs are also much higher.
Thatch Roofs are Eco Friendly , why should Thatch Property owners be penalised cost wise for using a natural product to protect their property Straw and Reed can be grown in abundabce for roofing of properties . The old ideas are the best .