A Sandown man who stole alcohol, clothes, pasties and even a quiche during a month-long theft spree has been handed an 18-month conditional discharge. Carl Etheridge, 48, of Royal Street in Sandown, admitted 4x theft from a shop when he appeared at the Isle of Wight Magistrates Court last week (19th January). On 12th September 2023, Etheridge entered the Co-op store on Sandown High Street and picked up 2 pasties and a quiche – valued at £6.30 – and left the store making no attempts to pay. Then, on 27th September, he entered the Sainsbury’s store just up the road and placed a bottle of Mill Grove wine in his pocket and left the store. He then did the same little over a week later on, on 5th October. Later in the month, Etheridge entered Sports Direct in Newport and took 9 Nike tops off the shelf and attempted to leave the store, the tags and coat-hangers still attached. He was stopped as he attempted to leave. Defending, Barry Keel said that the majority of the items stolen were low value and that Etheridge was struggling with his benefits at the time. In relation to the theft from Sports Direct, it was suggested that Etheridge was ‘pressured’ by someone to commit the crime. The 48-year-old was handed an 18-month conditional discharge and ordered to pay £26.60 in compensation.
MAN WHO STOLE PASTIES AND QUICHE HANDED 18-MONTH CONDITIONAL DISCHARGE
A
A
- Trending
- Comments
- Latest
POLICE AND FIREFIGHTERS REMAIN AT SCENE OF SANDOWN HOTEL BLAZE
11th October 2026
POLICE OFFICERS TRAPPED AS RESPONSE CAR HANGS OFF RYDE PIER
13th October 2026
OVERNIGHT BLAZE TAKES HOLD OF DERELICT SANDOWN HOTEL
11th October 2026
38-YEAR-OLD ARRESTED AFTER DOUBLE STABBING IN SHANKLIN
12th October 2026
WOMAN ACCUSED OF DRINK DRIVING CLAIMS BADGER CAUSED HER TO CRASH
16th October 2026
ISLAND DARTS STAR HELPS RAISE FUNDS FOR 3-YEAR-OLD BATTLING RARE CANCER
16th October 2026
TOP STORIES THIS WEEK
-
POLICE AND FIREFIGHTERS REMAIN AT SCENE OF SANDOWN HOTEL BLAZE
-
POLICE OFFICERS TRAPPED AS RESPONSE CAR HANGS OFF RYDE PIER
-
FORCE SAYS POLICE OFFICERS WERE RESPONDING TO INCIDENT BEFORE RYDE PIER CRASH
-
OVERNIGHT BLAZE TAKES HOLD OF DERELICT SANDOWN HOTEL
-
38-YEAR-OLD ARRESTED AFTER DOUBLE STABBING IN SHANKLIN
.
Sign up to our daily newsletter
Sign up to the daily newsletter and to get our top Isle of Wight news stories sent to you inbox every day.

External Links
© 2024 Island Echo Ltd. (10015091) is a company registered in England and Wales. Registered address: Fortis House, Cothey Way, Ryde, Isle of Wight PO33 1QT. VAT: 358464857 (V5)
















































































Why shouldn’t he just walk out without paying. Clearly the court condones his actions.
So the island court now operates a “steal now, pay later scheme” (but only if you get caught).
“Even a quiche”! Outrageous.
It could have been a tarte citron.Even worse.
That explains why he did not deliver my £10 Nike sweatshirt to me.Too busy eating pies.
Defending, Barry Keel said that the majority of the items stolen were low value, a bit like his life.
Low value or not, he is a grown man and he should be put in the stocks in the town square and have frozen quiche thrown at him for a week.
Gee whiz, that sentence will really teach him – not. Thick magistrates as usual, promoting crime.
That is what I call taking the biscuit
That’s what you get for coming up with some half baked scheme!
2 pasties and a quiche valued at £6.30 Public enemy number 1!