Plans to merge police forces into huge regional organisations could see the Isle of Wight placed under the control of a single Chief Constable responsible for much of the South East, prompting warnings that local policing and accountability could suffer.
Hampshire and Isle of Wight Police and Crime Commissioner Donna Jones is urging the Government to abandon proposals that could see the number of police forces across England and Wales reduced from 43 to as few as 9.
The warning comes ahead of a Government-backed review of police force structures, which is expected to recommend sweeping changes to the way policing is organised.
Jones has joined other Police and Crime Commissioners in writing to the Prime Minister, arguing that there is no evidence that larger police forces deliver better results.
Under one potential regional arrangement, a single Chief Constable could oversee an area stretching from Essex to the New Forest, and from the Isle of Wight to Milton Keynes.
The Commissioner says such an enormous geographical area would make it difficult for senior officers to understand the needs of individual communities.
A consultation carried out across Hampshire and the Isle of Wight has revealed widespread opposition to the proposals.
Of the 2,954 people who responded, 71.36% opposed police force mergers, while just 16.62% supported them.
Almost 75% believed accountability to local communities would decline, while 69.60% feared a reduction in visible neighbourhood policing.
Rather than merging forces, 46.92% of respondents favoured greater collaboration between neighbouring police forces while keeping them as separate organisations.
A further 30.91% wanted existing local policing arrangements retained.
Donna Jones, Police and Crime Commissioner, has said:
“If the government goes ahead with collapsing 43 forces into just nine mega-forces, just one Chief Constable will be responsible for the whole of the southeast of England. That means they would oversee an area from the border of Essex to the edge of the New Forest, and from the southern tip of the Isle of Wight to Milton Keynes.
“That geographical area is far too big for any Chief Constable to truly understand.
“Hampshire & Isle of Wight Constabulary is already one of the largest police forces in the country and far larger than many of our neighbouring forces.”
Jones has also warned that a major restructuring could undo investment in neighbourhood policing made since she was elected in 2021, while diverting resources away from frontline services.
She claims crime across Hampshire has fallen by 11% following increases in police officer numbers and fears that merging forces could reverse that progress.
The Commissioner added:
“Merging police forces will undoubtedly undo the investment in local policing I have spearheaded since being elected in 2021. The restructuring process alone will be expensive and it will distract policing from its core purpose.
“Hampshire residents have made clear, they don’t want half-baked plans to create mega forces, they simply want the Government to invest more into local policing.”
The joint letter to the Prime Minister also raises concerns that creating 9 regional forces could result in council tax increases for millions of households.
Jones warned:
“Communities will see and feel the impact of this for years to come, on the streets and in their pocket.”
The Government-backed review has yet to be published, and no final decision on the proposed police force mergers has been announced.





















































































