A long-running legal battle over plans for hundreds of new homes in Ryde has finally come to an end, with the Court of Appeal rejecting a final attempt to challenge planning permission.
The Court of Appeal has refused Greenfields (IOW) Ltd permission to appeal against an earlier High Court decision concerning Captiva Homes’ 473-home development in Elmfield, known as West Acre Park.
Lord Justice Lewison has rejected all 5 grounds advanced by the campaign group, as well as an application to introduce fresh evidence. Crucially, the judge concluded that it was ‘not arguable’ that the Isle of Wight Council’s planning committee had been misled when considering the development.
The decision brings the latest round of legal proceedings to a definitive conclusion, with the court order confirming that the refusal of permission to appeal is final and cannot be further reviewed or appealed. It means that work at West Acre Park can push ahead, with the first families set to move into their new homes in April 2027.
It marks a significant milestone in a planning saga that has lasted more than 7 years, during which the development has faced repeated objections, planning committee decisions and challenges through the courts.
It was in September 2019 that Island Echo exclusively revealed Captiva’s original plans for 465 homes at West Acre Park. The proposals subsequently evolved into the 473-home scheme that is now under construction.
The latest proceedings followed a second legal challenge brought by Greenfields after the Isle of Wight Council approved the development again in September 2025.
That fresh approval was necessary after Greenfields successfully challenged an earlier permission, with the Court of Appeal ruling that the council had failed to properly publish a Section 106 planning obligation. However, the scheme was approved again by councillors in a 7-4 vote, prompting another legal challenge which was rejected by the High Court earlier this year.
In his latest ruling, Lord Justice Lewison dismissed claims that planning councillors had been misled over the £1.5million cost of highway improvements and potential land acquisition at Westridge Cross.
Describing the challenge as based on a ‘hyper critical’ reading of the planning officer’s report, he concluded:
“It is not arguable that the Committee were misled.”
The judge also rejected arguments concerning the council’s handling of potential legal costs, a lack of transparency over highway contributions and the refusal to adjourn an earlier hearing when Greenfields was without legal representation.
An attempt to introduce fresh valuation evidence was also refused, with Lord Justice Lewison finding that it did not come close to undermining the council’s assessment of potential land acquisition costs.
The lengthy dispute has come at a considerable cost to the public purse. In January, Island Echo revealed that the Isle of Wight Council had spent more than £152,000 on the earlier court battle, excluding some officer time and the costs of subsequent proceedings.
Iain Delaney, Captiva Homes CEO, has said:
“We are naturally delighted with the Court of Appeal’s decision, which brings an end to what has been a lengthy and, at times, frustrating legal process.
“Throughout this period, our commitment to West Acre Park has never changed. We have always believed in the development, the quality of the homes we’re delivering and, most importantly, the positive contribution it can make to Ryde.
“One of the things we’re particularly proud of is that more than 85% of our Phase One residents are Islanders. These are local people, local families and people who already call the Isle of Wight home, choosing to build their futures here.
“That is what West Acre Park is really about, and it’s something that can sometimes get lost amongst the headlines surrounding planning and legal challenges.”




















































































