The Isle of Wight Council is considering switching off its CCTV system to save more than £78,000 a year, 7 years after a previous attempt to slash CCTV provision led to a partial U-turn.
The proposal forms part of the council’s Savings and Transformation Plan for 2027/28 onwards, which is due to be considered by the Policy, Finance and Resources Committee on Thursday (19th November).
The proposal simply states “CCTV System to be turned off”, with an anticipated saving of £78,331 annually from 2028/29.
The potential shutdown comes against a backdrop of previous controversy over CCTV provision on the Isle of Wight…
In April 2019, Island Echo exclusively revealed that the council was planning to effectively mothball the CCTV control room at Island Roads’ Newport headquarters, axing its 5 operators as part of savings to the highways PFI contract.
At the time, 100 cameras were monitored around the clock, allowing operators to follow incidents as they unfolded and alert emergency services.
Active monitoring ended on 17th May 2019, although cameras continued recording footage for retrospective use by the Police.
However, following concerns from Hampshire & Isle of Wight Constabulary, the council made a partial U-turn just weeks later, agreeing to allocate approximately £100,000 to support the CCTV service. This allowed officers to continue accessing recorded footage, viewing specific cameras and using the control room during police operations.
In October 2023, Island Echo reported that Councillor Karen Lucioni, then the council’s cabinet member for community protection, was on a ‘personal crusade’ to restore full CCTV monitoring. At that time, just 1 person was reported to be working in the control room.
More recently, in April 2025, then-Superintendent Robert Mitchell told councillors that greater CCTV provision would make a difference in tackling crime on the Isle of Wight. He acknowledged, however, that providing such a service was expensive and challenging amid financial pressures.
The latest savings proposal raises fresh questions about the future of the council’s CCTV network, particularly given the previous concerns raised by Police and elected members.
The budget document does not identify which cameras would be affected, whether recording facilities would cease entirely or what would happen to the control room.
Council officers acknowledge that the move would have a significant reputational impact and say discussions should take place with partner organisations, including the Police, before any possible implementation.
No decision has yet been taken to switch off the system, with final decisions on the 2027/28 budget expected in February 2027.
The potential CCTV shutdown comes alongside other proposed savings previously highlighted by Island Echo, including switching off street lights for 4 hours every night and reducing the number of winter gritting routes from 6 to 4.


















































































